search icon
search icon
Flag Arrow Down
Română
Română
Magyar
Magyar
English
English
Français
Français
Deutsch
Deutsch
Italiano
Italiano
Español
Español
Русский
Русский
日本語
日本語
中国人
中国人

Change Language

arrow down
  • Română
    Română
  • Magyar
    Magyar
  • English
    English
  • Français
    Français
  • Deutsch
    Deutsch
  • Italiano
    Italiano
  • Español
    Español
  • Русский
    Русский
  • 日本語
    日本語
  • 中国人
    中国人
Sections
  • News
  • Exclusive
  • INSCOP Surveys
  • Podcast
  • EU
  • Diaspora
  • Republic of Moldova
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Current Affairs
  • International
  • Sport
  • Health
  • Education
  • IT&C knowledge
  • Arts & Lifestyle
  • Opinions
  • Elections 2025
  • Environment
About Us
Contact
Privacy policy
Terms and conditions
Quickly scroll through news digests and see how they are covered in different publications!
  • News
  • Exclusive
    • INSCOP Surveys
    • Podcast
    • EU
    • Diaspora
    • Republic of Moldova
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Current Affairs
    • International
    • Sport
    • Health
    • Education
    • IT&C knowledge
    • Arts & Lifestyle
    • Opinions
    • Elections 2025
    • Environment
130 new news items in the last 24 hours
  1. Home
  2. Opinions

Andrei Cornea: Under the Shock of Violence

Andrei Cornea, Dilema.ro
whatsapp
facebook
linkedin
x
copy-link copy-link
30 October 2026, 09:20
main event image
Opinions
Foto Facebook
google-preference

Always see our news on Google

It is known that, toward the end of his life, in his essay “Beyond the Pleasure Principle,” Sigmund Freud formulated the hypothesis that the human psyche might be the battleground of two drives more elementary than the “pleasure principle,” which he had considered fundamental in his earlier works: these are the “life instinct” and the “death instinct” – Eros and Thanatos. The former would tend to encourage the expansion of life and its organization into increasingly complex forms; the latter, by contrast, would seek to bring life back to earlier forms, that is, to dead matter. Here, then, is the ultimate explanation of sadism, cruelty, and apparently purposeless and irrational violence – directed both at one's fellow human beings and at animals: the pure, senseless pleasure of destroying would be the expression of the “death instinct” – Thanatos.

This explanation – on the borderline between mythology and psychology – came to mind as I noted the outburst of absurd and destructive violence in the cities of France two Saturdays ago. How can one credibly and comprehensively explain, by “normal” means – economic, sociological, political, demographic – the burning of town halls or schools, the destruction of shops, looting, and other acts of violence? I know: the radical left always blames unsatisfactory living conditions, the decline in living standards, exorbitant rents, the marginalization of certain social groups, etc.; the populist right denounces the excessive number of immigrants, especially from countries in Africa and Asia. They are all partly right, to a greater or lesser extent, but beyond these partial explanations and many others of this kind, I wonder whether something deeper is at work here: why burn schools when the protests broke out among students dissatisfied precisely with the number and facilities of the schools? Why vandalize or burn town halls? Mayors do not decide national economic policy. Why fight the gendarmes? You will not manage to defeat them, nor is it believable that the demands of a violent and anarchic mass will be heeded. You are more likely to trigger a backlash. Why vandalize shops whose employees have done you no harm and whose owners pay the taxes from which you receive your allowances and social benefits? Of course, you will say that the unleashed gangs were not engaging in economic reasoning but, driven by anger and resentment, were destroying everything they happened to find in their path. But that is exactly what Freud's theory says too: when freed from “civilized” restraints, we may witness the violent, furious unleashing of a mass that destroys without reasoning, solely out of the delight of destroying. It is a kind of aggression that is frightening not only because of its victims and material and economic damage but, above all, because of the useless, irrational, and disproportionate nature of the violence in relation to the modest possible gain. Well, does not this irrationality, this nonsense, amount to Thanatos?And apropos of the recent devastation in European cities: it is natural for the right and the left (especially when they move well away from the center) to have different, even opposite, answers to nearly all the sociopolitical problems I referred to above. But it is curious that sometimes their interpretations are so diametrically opposed that, paradoxically, they end up resembling each other in their less anticipated consequences. For example, Professor Valentin Naumescu, presidential adviser, maintains in an essay (“Under Assault by Revolutionary Socialism. The Impact on the EU”) that the far-left and far-right ideologies assaulting the liberal center are nothing other than “revolutionary socialism.” This would currently be “dressed up either as neo-Marxism, wokism, Occupy, radical socialist environmentalism... etc., or as neo-Nazism, supremacist movements, etc.” The distinction between Nazism and communism, for example, or between neo-Marxism and Legionaryism, would therefore be merely an appearance. I do not at all deny that there are many similarities between the extremes, as well as reciprocal influences, but it does not seem productive to me at all to ignore the differences between them, manifested over time in their values, intellectual genealogies, solutions, treatment of the economy, attitudes toward ethnicity, race, class, etc.

On the other hand, I am reading a text on Facebook by Teodora Dumitru (literary critic, researcher at the “G. Călinescu” Institute), who firmly declares that “there was no communism in Romania” (nor in the other countries of the “socialist bloc”!) But what was it that put us in chains for decades? Only “state capitalism.” (An old leftist theory, incidentally, nothing new!)

Thus, one person confidently declares that, ideologically speaking, there is only “revolutionary socialism,” and that everything we have seen in the world for more than a century is merely an avatar of one and the same current, and that to believe otherwise is to succumb to an epistemic illusion. Someone else, with at least as much aplomb, wants to teach us “as if we were toddlers” that socialism (“revolutionary” or otherwise) neither exists nor has ever existed, either here or in general. Another epistemic illusion! One says: there are only disguises of capitalism. The other says: no, the disguises belong to socialism! In either case, distinctions and specificities disappear or become insignificant – which, beyond the debatable seriousness of the detailed analysis, seems to me methodologically flawed through and through.

Forgive me, but it is as if someone were to claim that all dogs are “disguised” cats, while someone else insisted that, in fact and in reality, cats are merely dogs in feline camouflage! Would it not nevertheless be simpler to repeat the old platitude that, because cats and dogs are two different species (united, of course, under the common genus of carnivores), neither is barking undercover meowing, nor vice versa?

Latest News

20:44

Nicușor Dan warns about the deficit as the Government considers whether pensions and salaries can be increased in 2027

20:37

Nicusor Dan rejects the comparison with “Yalta 2.0” and says the Trump-Putin-Xi meeting does not change the international order

20:34

Nicușor Dan clarified that his statement regarding fear of 2028 refers to the possible outcome of the parliamentary elections

20:29

LIBE Committee calls for EUR 13.31 billion for asylum and migration in 2028–2034 and minimum allocations for asylum and integration

20:15

Timișoara Airport will resume flights on November 22, after runway works are completed

See more news

NEWS ON THE SAME TOPICS

event image
Opinions
Sever Voinescu: Merit, Privilege, Responsibility—Total Loss
event image
Opinions
Andrei Cornea: A perennial conflict
event image
Opinions
Sever Voinescu: Which kind of extremism do you prefer, right-wing or left-wing?
event image
International
Informat.ro Summary / Why Europe Is Protesting: from schools without teachers and unaffordable rents to looted shops and a city hall set on fire
event image
Opinions
Andrei Pleșu: The Homeland and the World
event image
Opinions
Andrei Pleșu: What Is Allowed and What Is Not
app preview
Personalized news feed, AI-powered search, and notifications in a more interactive experience.
app preview app preview
Sigmund Freud Andrei Cornea literary criticism Teodora Dumitru political ideologies

Editor’s Recommendations

main event image
INSCOP Surveys
11 hours ago

November 2026: Informat.ro – INSCOP Research BAROMETER, 15th Edition – Chapter X: Temporary Restriction of Access to Online Platforms

main event image
Politics
46 minutes ago

Nicușor Dan, about Marian Neacșu: “A professional”

Sources
imagine sursa
imagine sursa
main event image
Exclusive
4 hours ago

EXCLUSIVE Ranking of companies in relevant online sources in Romania: Nvidia dominates company visibility. Finance and investments lead the economic agenda

main event image
Opinions
9 hours ago

Andrei Pleșu: What Our Ministers Were and What They Have Become

main event image
Exclusive
10 hours ago

EXCLUSIVE The top domestic political topics trending over the past week / The Lyrica shortage crisis, Marian Neacșu’s new responsibilities, and debates over administrative reform

app preview
Personalized news feed, AI-powered search, and notifications in a more interactive experience.
app preview
app store badge google play badge
  • News
  • Exclusive
  • INSCOP Surveys
  • Podcast
  • EU
  • Diaspora
  • Republic of Moldova
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Current Affairs
  • International
  • Sport
  • Health
  • Education
  • IT&C knowledge
  • Arts & Lifestyle
  • Opinions
  • Elections 2025
  • Environment
  • About Us
  • Contact
Privacy policy
Cookies Policy
Terms and conditions
Open source licenses
All rights reserved Strategic Media Team SRL

Technology in partnership with

anpc-sal anpc-sol