search icon
search icon
Flag Arrow Down
Română
Română
Magyar
Magyar
English
English
Français
Français
Deutsch
Deutsch
Italiano
Italiano
Español
Español
Русский
Русский
日本語
日本語
中国人
中国人

Change Language

arrow down
  • Română
    Română
  • Magyar
    Magyar
  • English
    English
  • Français
    Français
  • Deutsch
    Deutsch
  • Italiano
    Italiano
  • Español
    Español
  • Русский
    Русский
  • 日本語
    日本語
  • 中国人
    中国人
Sections
  • News
  • Exclusive
  • INSCOP Surveys
  • Podcast
  • EU
  • Diaspora
  • Republic of Moldova
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Current Affairs
  • International
  • Sport
  • Health
  • Education
  • IT&C knowledge
  • Arts & Lifestyle
  • Opinions
  • Elections 2025
  • Environment
About Us
Contact
Privacy policy
Terms and conditions
Quickly scroll through news digests and see how they are covered in different publications!
  • News
  • Exclusive
    • INSCOP Surveys
    • Podcast
    • EU
    • Diaspora
    • Republic of Moldova
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Current Affairs
    • International
    • Sport
    • Health
    • Education
    • IT&C knowledge
    • Arts & Lifestyle
    • Opinions
    • Elections 2025
    • Environment
134 new news items in the last 24 hours
  1. Home
  2. Diaspora

The CJEU finds that Hungary and the Czech Republic breached the right to a lawyer through rules that generally allowed suspects to be questioned without legal counsel

2eu.brussels
whatsapp
facebook
linkedin
x
copy-link copy-link
22 October 2026, 19:44
main event image
EU
Foto: 2eu.brussels
google-preference

Always see our news on Google

The unavailability of a lawyer and national time limits do not automatically justify questioning without legal assistance. The judgments allow solutions such as appointing another lawyer and, in exceptional circumstances, digital participation. Hungary also breached the safeguards concerning waiving the right to a lawyer.

On Thursday, 22 October 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union found that Hungary and Czechia had breached European law through rules that generally allowed suspects to be questioned without a lawyer when counsel was unavailable within the time limits laid down by national legislation. The CJEU fully upheld the actions brought by the European Commission: the mere expiry of a time limit or the impossibility of contacting a lawyer, in themselves, do not justify restricting the right of defence.

In brief

The CJEU fully upheld the Commission’s actions against Hungary and Czechia. The unavailability of a lawyer or the expiry of national time limits does not automatically justify questioning without counsel.

In Hungary, a postponement of at least two hours after the lawyer had been informed was provided for. In Czechia, the 48-hour period concerned detention and appearance before a court, not a mandatory waiting period before questioning.

The lawyer must be present and participate effectively, in principle in person. Digital means remain possible in exceptional circumstances, provided that they fully ensure the right of defence.

Authorities may appoint another available lawyer. Questioning without a lawyer requires a valid waiver, where permitted, or an exceptional derogation, individually reasoned and subject to judicial review.

Hungary also breached its obligations concerning waiver of the right to a lawyer: clear information, a voluntary decision, recording, and the possibility of revocation. The Court assessed the situation in 2023, without taking into account the Hungarian amendment of December 2024.

The judgments impose no fines and do not automatically annul previous questioning or convictions. The states must comply, and individual breaches must be capable of being effectively challenged. There is no finding against Romania.

The Hungarian rules examined by the Court provided for questioning to be postponed for at least two hours after the lawyer had been informed, but allowed it to begin if the lawyer did not appear. In Czechia, the possibility of questioning without a lawyer was linked to counsel’s unavailability during the 48-hour period following detention. This period concerned bringing the suspect before a court to request detention or release; it was not a mandatory waiting period before interrogation.

The judges emphasised that the right of access to a lawyer entails the lawyer’s presence and effective participation in the questioning, not merely the suspect’s ability to contact one. Presence must, in principle, be in person. In exceptional circumstances, it may also be ensured by other means, including digital means, if these guarantee the full and effective exercise of the right of defence.

The absence of the chosen lawyer does not require the authorities to wait indefinitely, nor does it allow them to automatically continue without legal assistance. The Court points to the possibility of appointing another available lawyer. Questioning without a lawyer may take place if the person validly waives that right, where defence is not mandatory, or if the strict conditions for a temporary derogation are met. However, the appointment of a lawyer does not mean that assistance must be free of charge in every situation; state-funded legal aid is subject to its own conditions.

Derogations allowing questioning without a lawyer are reserved for exceptional circumstances before trial: an emergency to protect a person’s life, liberty or physical integrity, or an overriding need to act immediately to prevent serious jeopardising of the criminal proceedings. The decision must be reasoned in relation to the specific case, recorded, and subject to judicial review. The restriction must be proportionate, strictly limited in time, and must not affect the fairness of the proceedings.

In Hungary’s case, the CJEU also found that the safeguards concerning waiver of the right to a lawyer had not been transposed. Even though the right was regarded as inalienable under national legislation, the suspect’s decision not to exercise it had, in practice, the effect of a waiver. The person must receive clear information about the right and the consequences of waiving it, decide voluntarily and unequivocally, and have the choice and the circumstances surrounding it recorded. The waiver may subsequently be revoked, with effect for the future, and the person must be informed of this possibility.

The finding concerning Hungary relates to the legal situation at the expiry of the deadline set by the Commission in the pre-litigation procedure, in 2023. The Court did not take into account the legislative amendment published in December 2024, as it was subsequent to that point. The judgment therefore does not constitute a complete assessment of all Hungarian rules currently in force.

The two decisions are judgments against states for failure to comply with European obligations, not rulings in individual criminal proceedings. They do not automatically annul previous questioning, evidence or convictions. However, the Directive requires an effective remedy in cases of breaches of rights and respect for the defence and fairness of the proceedings when statements and evidence obtained without respect for the right to a lawyer are assessed.

Hungary and Czechia must comply with the judgments without delay. The Court ordered them to pay the Commission’s legal costs, without imposing fines in these cases; any failure to comply may lead to a new action in which the Commission seeks financial penalties. The interpretation of the Directive is also relevant to Romania, to which the same European safeguards apply, but the judgments do not find any breach by the Romanian authorities.

https://2eu.brussels/ro/news/cjue-decide-ca-suspectii-nu-pot-fi-audiati-fara-avocat-doar-pentru-ca-acesta-intarzie

Latest News

22:43

A delivery driver from Sri Lanka attacked in Iași County. The attacker destroyed his scooter and phone

22:27

Ilie Bolojan, on the risk of the PNL splitting: “We do not expect anyone to leave the party”

22:04

Donald Trump announces good talks with Vladimir Putin and says that the Russian leader wants to end the war in Ukraine through diplomatic means

21:51

Zohran Mamdani announces the closure of the Rikers Island prison complex by 2032

21:21

EUROCONTROL blocks the sums owed to ROMATSA again / The garnishment was imposed at Pfizer’s request in the dispute concerning COVID-19 vaccines

See more news

NEWS ON THE SAME TOPICS

event image
EU
The ECHR clarifies in an advisory opinion that a lawyer’s absence from a disciplinary hearing does not justify automatically excluding representation
event image
International
CJEU: Hungary breached EU law by the automatic release and expulsion of human traffickers
event image
EU
The CJEU says teachers’ holiday pay must also include income from a second contract
event image
EU
Access to lawyers and challenges to detention remain difficult for asylum seekers in Europe, ECRE says
event image
EU
The EU General Court rejects, for lack of jurisdiction, Hungary’s action against the financing of the Ukrainian army from the proceeds of frozen Russian assets
event image
EU
Commission refers Austria to the CJEU over mandatory refusal of certain European arrest warrants concerning Austrian nationals
app preview
Personalized news feed, AI-powered search, and notifications in a more interactive experience.
app preview app preview
Hungary Czech Republic CJEU EU

Editor’s Recommendations

main event image
Current Affairs
1 hour ago

EUROCONTROL blocks the sums owed to ROMATSA again / The garnishment was imposed at Pfizer’s request in the dispute concerning COVID-19 vaccines

Sources
imagine sursa
imagine sursa
imagine sursa
imagine sursa
main event image
Exclusive
12 hours ago

EXCLUSIVE | Romania, as viewed by the Russian press / The scenario of unification with the Republic of Moldova, described as a “capitulation” of Chișinău

main event image
Opinions
7 hours ago

Andrei Cornea: Politics, Ethics and Fanaticism

app preview
Personalized news feed, AI-powered search, and notifications in a more interactive experience.
app preview
app store badge google play badge
  • News
  • Exclusive
  • INSCOP Surveys
  • Podcast
  • EU
  • Diaspora
  • Republic of Moldova
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Current Affairs
  • International
  • Sport
  • Health
  • Education
  • IT&C knowledge
  • Arts & Lifestyle
  • Opinions
  • Elections 2025
  • Environment
  • About Us
  • Contact
Privacy policy
Cookies Policy
Terms and conditions
Open source licenses
All rights reserved Strategic Media Team SRL

Technology in partnership with

anpc-sal anpc-sol