The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has barred a Romanian lawyer, for two years, from representing or assisting litigants before the Court after finding that he used artificial intelligence to draft legal submissions. The decision was taken on 13 November in a case in which the lawyer was one of the applicants’ two representatives.
The documents submitted contained numerous errors concerning ECHR case law: non-existent, “hallucinated” cases, fictitious paragraphs attributed to genuine judgments, as well as irrelevant decisions or decisions that contradicted the arguments being advanced. The lawyer acknowledged using artificial intelligence programs, but described the problems as simple inaccuracies and citation errors.
The ECHR Chamber considered that the mistakes were numerous, repeated and substantial, indicating a pattern rather than isolated incidents. The lawyer had failed to properly verify the references in the official HUDOC case-law database, although some of the errors could have been identified through a simple check.
The Court concluded that this conduct breached the lawyer’s professional and ethical obligations and affected the administration of justice. The procedure required additional checks and extensive correspondence with the parties involved. The President of the ECHR approved the Chamber’s proposal to impose the ban. The measure applies only to this lawyer and is not final; his rights may be restored under the conditions set out in the Court’s rules.
Sources
Latest News
20:24
20:13
20:01
19:53
19:45
See more news