“What this scoundrel of a president is doing is absolutely unacceptable. At this point he has buried everything and buried himself as well, politically and morally. From this moment on, this piece of trash no longer exists for me. A bastard.” That is what journalist Ovidiu Vanghele wrote, if I understand correctly, after President Nicușor Dan appointed the heads of the prosecution offices. Let me remind you, those appointments were extremely controversial, and many people were very angry with the president at the time. Journalist Ovidiu Vanghele was evidently among the angriest and wrote these lines on the walls of the Facebook temple.
Reading them, a normal person would wonder why the journalist went to the press conference on November 10 at all, if the “scoundrel” president “no longer exists” for him. But normal people have no place in the world of political cheerleaders and the indignant; only vigilant and nervous people are found there, fierce lovers of rights and thirsting for the justice of destroying their adversary. It would not be difficult for me to anticipate the reply I might receive: “It doesn’t matter what he says, he is a journalist and his duty is to inform, and it is our right to be informed by Mr. Vanghele about the state of the country, so it is normal for him to question the president.”
I will return to our right to be informed and the president’s obligation to inform us, but before that I would like to recall the incident. Mr. Vanghele attended the press conference of the scoundrel piece of trash who had ceased to exist and asked him, rather convolutedly, whether the vote cast by the prosecutor general at a CSM meeting concerning the initiation of an investigation by the Judicial Inspection targeting her personally was “part of the Justice reform that you were proposing to citizens... during the campaign.” The president replied: “...in view of the insults you have directed at me, I have ordered that you no longer attend press conferences at Cotroceni Palace at this time, during this term.”
As far as I am concerned, I understood President Nicușor Dan’s reaction. Since I do not follow the journalist’s activity, it took me some time to find out why the president was upset. I came across the post above and, I say openly, moved from understanding to agreement with and support for the president’s attitude. I am familiar with all the ECHR decisions that grant journalists greater freedom of expression when writing opinions about politicians, and I am familiar with the legislation that grants journalists, as representatives of the press, the right to ask questions and report the answer as they see fit. Knowing—all modesty aside, but that is the case—these things better than many of Facebook’s leading figures, I say that the president acted not only morally correctly, but also lawfully in relation to Mr. Vanghele.
The Presidency had every justification to believe that someone who writes such things on Facebook is intent on hurling insults at the press conference for which he had requested accreditation, thereby disrupting it. With the post in hand, the president’s staff could lawfully have refused to accredit Mr. Vanghele. But although the president instructed them to do so, they did not. What is interesting is that, after Mr. Vanghele behaved very civilly at the press conference and even publicly stated afterward that he regretted the insulting words he had written, there is no longer any real legal reason to refuse his accreditation for future press conferences.
I believe it was good that Mr. Nicușor Dan asserted this authority at the press conference on November 10. It is good for the public in general, but also for him as a politician. Perhaps it is not good from an electoral standpoint. Other presidents (Iliescu, Băsescu) did things of this kind with a substantial faction of the press on their side; they had allies. Nicușor Dan has absolutely no allies in our press, and on social media he is being torn to pieces. His enemies dominate the media field authoritatively. Nicușor Dan is on the defensive, hemmed in; he is, as they say, “being pulverized.” This was also evident on the occasion of this incident—almost nobody supported him.
But something else astonished me. Those who organized the president’s press conference disobeyed the instruction not to have the journalist in the room. I know how difficult it is to receive such an instruction from the president: we are holding a press conference open to everyone, but so-and-so cannot enter. The journalist, obviously, shows up. He invokes the law and the sacred right to information, of which he himself is the apostle. How do you keep him out without causing a scandal? Especially since he is a potentially aggressive journalist who has insulted the president in the past. It is difficult, but an order is an order and, somehow, you have to carry it out, trying as best you can to avoid a scandal, because the legal basis, as I said above, existed.
In any event, it is a fact that the president’s order was not carried out by the people in his immediate entourage. I have long felt that Nicușor Dan does not project power within the system. Here, I have proof that this is so. To me, this seems the most worrying thing revealed at the November 10 press conference: if even the president’s own people do not obey him, then what can we say about the formidable “system boys,” his inevitable adversaries within the system, “other people’s men,” officials, officers, or magistrates who, as the saying goes, take their orders elsewhere?
Such disturbing confirmations do not come alone. A few days later, I learned from the press that, at the press conference, the president had committed one of his most regrettable errors; indeed, I would say he had made a fool of himself. I am among those who believe that Mr. Nicușor Dan is fundamentally mistaken regarding the Justice system. Just as I agree with him on some matters, I do not agree with him regarding Justice. I, too, mocked him when he boldly announced a judicial referendum on the CSM—a foolishness, something absolutely impossible to organize and entirely pointless. At that point, I understood that no matter how many hours he had spent in court litigating various civic causes, Mr. Nicușor Dan had not understood the system’s major problems. Or, more precisely, he had not understood all of them. Just as he had ventured onto misguided paths when he promised the referendum, he now finds himself equally lost, but on different roads, in the opposite direction. It seemed very strange to me that he asked magistrates who did not want to be lined up in the Savonea battalion to provide evidence that they were being persecuted, saying at the press conference that not one of them had brought him documents or proof. Yet a few days later, a female judge told the press (hotnews.ro) that she had sent such a file some time earlier to the presidential adviser responsible for the matter. When the judge asked whether he had informed the president, the adviser mumbled. The situation is embarrassing on a human level and serious institutionally. One of two things is true: either the adviser informed the president and the president forgot or did not tell the truth at the press conference, or the adviser did not inform the president and the president was genuinely exposed to this awkward situation in which the documents he was asking for had long been at the Presidency.
In any case, the feeling that Mr. Nicușor Dan does not even properly control the courtyard of Cotroceni Palace is unsettling. In these times, the president’s lack of political and institutional authority is a vulnerability for the country. I know, the president is alone, he has no party, and the parties are running rampant through state offices as if in a village without a watchdog. I know, Mr. Nicușor Dan is not the authoritarian type; he is merely a stubborn NGO activist, descended from a mathematician accustomed to there being only himself and the equations in his mind in the world. I also know that it is his fault that he is alone. That is how he wants it to be; it is not a given, but his choice. But this state, by its very nature undisciplined, arbitrary, and contradictory, needs a strong president today more than ever.
I believe that not everything is lost. I believe that Mr. Nicușor Dan can become a strong president. He still can. But he does not have much time left.
https://www.dilema.ro/tilc-show/peripetiile-unei-conferinte-de-presa
Latest News
21:00
20:45
20:30
20:15
19:57
See more news