search icon
search icon
Flag Arrow Down
Română
Română
Magyar
Magyar
English
English
Français
Français
Deutsch
Deutsch
Italiano
Italiano
Español
Español
Русский
Русский
日本語
日本語
中国人
中国人

Change Language

arrow down
  • Română
    Română
  • Magyar
    Magyar
  • English
    English
  • Français
    Français
  • Deutsch
    Deutsch
  • Italiano
    Italiano
  • Español
    Español
  • Русский
    Русский
  • 日本語
    日本語
  • 中国人
    中国人
Sections
  • News
  • Exclusive
  • INSCOP Surveys
  • Podcast
  • EU
  • Diaspora
  • Republic of Moldova
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Current Affairs
  • International
  • Sport
  • Health
  • Education
  • IT&C knowledge
  • Arts & Lifestyle
  • Opinions
  • Elections 2025
  • Environment
About Us
Contact
Privacy policy
Terms and conditions
Quickly scroll through news digests and see how they are covered in different publications!
  • News
  • Exclusive
    • INSCOP Surveys
    • Podcast
    • EU
    • Diaspora
    • Republic of Moldova
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Current Affairs
    • International
    • Sport
    • Health
    • Education
    • IT&C knowledge
    • Arts & Lifestyle
    • Opinions
    • Elections 2025
    • Environment
137 new news items in the last 24 hours
  1. Home
  2. EU

ECHR condemns Romania over ineffective investigation into Iancu Sandu’s death during the Revolution

2eu.brussels
whatsapp
facebook
linkedin
x
copy-link copy-link
27 October 2026, 20:44
main event image
EU
2eu.brussels
google-preference

Always see our news on Google

The European Court of Human Rights found that the main investigation into the death of Iancu Sandu, who was shot in a hospital in Brașov in 1989, was ineffective. The conviction of the serviceman who fired the shot did not remove the obligation to investigate all the circumstances. The judgment is final: his wife and two children each receive 23,000 euros in non-pecuniary damages and 500 euros in costs.

Romania was condemned on Tuesday, 27 October, by the European Court of Human Rights for the ineffective investigation into the death of Iancu Sandu, who was shot on 24 December 1989 in the Brașov hospital where he was hospitalized. In a final judgment, the judges held that punishing the serviceman who fired the shot did not remove the authorities’ obligation to investigate the other circumstances and responsibilities as well. The victim’s wife and two children will each receive 23,000 euros in non-pecuniary damages and 500 euros for the costs of the proceedings.

In brief

1. The ECHR unanimously found a violation of the obligation to investigate arising from the right to life. The judgment in Sandu and Others v. Romania is final and concerns the manner in which the investigation was conducted, without determining the criminal liability of the persons in the Revolution File.

2. Iancu Sandu was shot dead in a hospital in Brașov on 24 December 1989. The applicants are his wife, Elisabeta, his daughter Silvia-Andrada, and his son Robert-Iancu.

3. The serviceman who fired the shot was finally convicted in 2001 and sentenced to three years and four months in prison. That conviction and the compensation awarded to his wife at the time for the death did not remedy the suffering and uncertainty caused by the ineffective main investigation.

4. The Court noted the excessive length of the investigation, the lengthy periods of inactivity, the victims’ insufficient participation, and the lack of information provided to the public. The investigation should have been capable of clarifying the circumstances of the operations as well, including their planning and control, where necessary.

5. The Revolution File was returned to the military prosecutors in September 2024. An official communication from Romania dated October 2025 records the return and the death of Ion Iliescu; the execution of judgments concerning the investigations into the Revolution was discussed again with the General Prosecutor’s Office in September 2026.

6. Romania must pay each of the three applicants 23,500 euros within three months: a total of 70,500 euros, plus any taxes provided for in the judgment. The Court did not examine separately the complaint concerning the length of the proceedings under the right to a fair trial.

The judgment in Sandu and Others v. Romania stems from two distinct investigations: one concerning the shooting of Iancu Sandu in Brașov and another, broader one, concerning the deaths that occurred during the Revolution. The family argued that the second case, in which the victim’s relatives joined as civil parties, had not clarified all the responsibilities for his death.

In the first case, the Military Court of Appeal finally convicted the serviceman who fired the shot, on 22 May 2001, of particularly serious murder. The sentence was three years and four months in prison. The court found that the manner in which he had opened fire violated military rules and ordered him, jointly and severally with the Ministry of Defence, to pay the victim’s wife 75 million old lei, equivalent to approximately 3,000 euros, for the material and moral damage caused by the death.

The Government relied on that conviction and compensation to argue that the family members could no longer claim victim status before the ECHR. The Strasbourg judges rejected the argument. The serviceman’s trial and the main investigation had sufficiently different subject matters, while the 2001 compensation concerned the loss of her husband, not the suffering and uncertainty caused by the way in which the broader investigation had been conducted.

The Court explained that, in such a case, investigators must be able to examine not only the actions of the person who directly used lethal force, but also the circumstances in which it was used. Where necessary to establish whether the State had complied with its obligation to protect life, the investigation must also include the planning and control of the operations. Identifying the shooter did not, in itself, close these questions.

The main investigation had been opened ex officio in 1990 by the military prosecutors. The ECHR examined it within the limits of its temporal jurisdiction, which began on 20 June 1994, the date Romania ratified the Convention. Reiterating its findings in previous cases concerning the Revolution, the Court noted the excessive length, the long periods of inactivity, the lack of sufficient involvement by the victims, and insufficient public information about the progress of the case. Its conclusion was that the Sandu family had been deprived of a fully effective investigation.

The finding concerns the procedural obligation arising from Article 2 of the Convention, which protects the right to life. The judgment does not establish who bears all the criminal responsibility for Iancu Sandu’s death and does not replace the domestic proceedings. Following this conclusion, the judges considered it unnecessary to examine separately the complaint concerning the length of the proceedings brought under Article 6, relating to a fair trial.

The history of the main investigation is linked to the Revolution File. In the domestic proceedings, former President Ion Iliescu, former Deputy Prime Minister Gelu Voican Voiculescu, and former commander of the Military Aviation, Iosif Rus, were committed for trial. Committing someone for trial is not equivalent to a conviction. After several preliminary-chamber stages, the High Court returned the file to the military prosecutors on 20 September 2024 because of irregularities in the indictment.

A communication sent by the Romanian authorities to the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe on 10 October 2025 states that the indictment did not allow the subject matter and limits of the trial to be established, and that the file had returned to the Military Prosecution Service. The document also records the death of Ion Iliescu on 5 August 2025. In the Sandu judgment, the ECHR describes the 2024 return and notes that the parties had not informed it of any subsequent procedural developments.

The issue of executing the judgments concerning the investigations into the Revolution remained on the Council of Europe’s agenda. The responsible department announced on 1 October 2026 that, during a mission to Bucharest on 23–24 September, it had discussed with representatives of the General Prosecutor’s Office the cases in the Association 21 December 1989 and Others group. The information concerns supervision of the execution of European judgments and does not announce a new committal for trial in the Revolution File.

For the non-pecuniary damage caused by the ineffective investigation, the ECHR awarded Elisabeta Sandu, Silvia-Andrada Sandu, and Robert-Iancu Sandu 23,000 euros each, plus 500 euros each for costs and expenses. Romania must pay the total of 70,500 euros within three months, together with any applicable taxes. The amounts are to be converted into lei at the exchange rate applicable on the date of payment, and late payment will attract the interest specified in the judgment.

https://2eu.brussels/ro/news/cedo-condamna-romania-pentru-ancheta-excesiv-de-lunga-privind-moartea-unui-barbat-la-revolutia-din-1989

Latest News

22:59

Sorin Grindeanu supports expanding the powers of Marian Neacșu, the sole deputy prime minister in the Niculescu Government

22:51

Alexandru Nazare announced the preparation of RoBOOST / The Fund will attract private capital for Romanian companies

22:45

Sorin Grindeanu calls for a clear picture of the country’s finances and announces that PSD does not support tax increases in 2027

22:37

The White House confiscated the phones of reporters aboard Air Force One when Donald Trump departed China, citing cybersecurity concerns

22:17

The Pentagon estimates the cost of the war at $48.3 billion, up 26% from the August assessment

See more news

NEWS ON THE SAME TOPICS

event image
Republic of Moldova
ECHR rejects Judge Dorin Munteanu’s application because he concealed the compensation proceedings in Moldova
event image
Current Affairs
ECHR condemns Romania over an unfair trial in the Sabyc fertility clinic case
event image
EU
ECHR condemns Moldova over ineffective investigation into homophobic violence at a march in Chișinău
event image
Current Affairs
The CJEU rules that a seven-year drug sentence alone does not justify refusing surrender to Romania
event image
EU
ECHR declares inadmissible Elit-Fitness club’s application concerning the gym rented in Chișinău
event image
EU
ECHR finds degrading treatment in the prolonged solitary confinement of two former Turkish judges
app preview
Personalized news feed, AI-powered search, and notifications in a more interactive experience.
app preview app preview
Romania Ion Iliescu ECHR gelu voican voiculescu 1989 revolution inquiry

Editor’s Recommendations

main event image
INSCOP Surveys
13 hours ago

November 2026: Informat.ro – INSCOP Research BAROMETER, 15th Edition – Chapter X: Temporary Restriction of Access to Online Platforms

main event image
Politics
3 hours ago

Nicușor Dan, about Marian Neacșu: “A professional”

Sources
imagine sursa
imagine sursa
imagine sursa
main event image
Exclusive
6 hours ago

EXCLUSIVE Ranking of companies in relevant online sources in Romania: Nvidia dominates company visibility. Finance and investments lead the economic agenda

main event image
Economy
3 hours ago

Anthropic debuted on Nasdaq at $111.50 per share and became the most valuable company listed through a public offering

Sources
imagine sursa
imagine sursa
main event image
Opinions
12 hours ago

Andrei Pleșu: What Our Ministers Were and What They Have Become

main event image
Exclusive
12 hours ago

EXCLUSIVE The top domestic political topics trending over the past week / The Lyrica shortage crisis, Marian Neacșu’s new responsibilities, and debates over administrative reform

app preview
Personalized news feed, AI-powered search, and notifications in a more interactive experience.
app preview
app store badge google play badge
  • News
  • Exclusive
  • INSCOP Surveys
  • Podcast
  • EU
  • Diaspora
  • Republic of Moldova
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Current Affairs
  • International
  • Sport
  • Health
  • Education
  • IT&C knowledge
  • Arts & Lifestyle
  • Opinions
  • Elections 2025
  • Environment
  • About Us
  • Contact
Privacy policy
Cookies Policy
Terms and conditions
Open source licenses
All rights reserved Strategic Media Team SRL

Technology in partnership with

anpc-sal anpc-sol