At the hearing on 16 November, the European Commission explained how authorities should demonstrate that short-term rentals significantly reduce the housing supply or make housing more expensive in a specific area before introducing restrictions under the proposed regulation on affordable housing. The draft requires evidence covering at least three years and an assessment of less restrictive measures. At the hearing on 16 November, organised by the European Parliament’s special committee on the housing crisis (HOUS), with the participation of the Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Protection (IMCO), the European Commission representative, Lucía Caudet, explained what authorities should demonstrate before restricting short-term rentals under the proposed regulation on affordable housing. Authorities should delineate the area where the housing market is under pressure, show how short-term rentals contribute to the problem, and justify why the chosen measure is necessary.
In brief
1.The proposal requires authorities to demonstrate that short-term rentals have significantly affected housing availability or affordability for at least three years before the measure is adopted.
2.To delineate areas under pressure, the draft uses the ratio between the price of a medium-sized home and annual disposable income per capita. The thresholds are eight and ten years of income, under different conditions.
3.Authorities should assess whether a less restrictive measure would produce equally good results within a reasonable period. The host’s primary residence is exempt from the short-term rental restrictions provided for under this framework.
4.The Parliament and the Council are examining the draft. The EU regulation on the collection and sharing of data on short-term rentals already applies.
How would authorities establish that an area is under pressureThe hearing raised the question of how well a common indicator can capture differences between local markets. Caudet presented the price-to-income ratio as a starting point and explained that the proposal aims to give authorities greater legal certainty in applying internal market rules. The Commission says it can provide data for this indicator at the level of NUTS 3 statistical regions. The decision on any potential restriction would fall to the competent authorities in the Member States.
According to Article 6 of proposal COM(2026) 599, the representative price of a medium-sized home in the area should equal at least eight years of disposable income per capita, and the price-to-income ratio should have increased during the most recent ten years for which data are available. At a ratio of at least ten years of income, the requirement concerning an increase would no longer apply. In both situations, the authority should show, based on population, supply and demand trends, that the pressure is unlikely to ease over the next three years in the absence of the measure. The draft allows more detailed local data to be used if the authority demonstrates that the resulting ratio is compatible with the proposed thresholds.
The European Holiday Home Association, which represents the sector, called for the use of data on short-term rentals to be mandatory before any restriction is examined. Caudet explained that the share of such rentals at EU level may conceal the situation in areas where they are concentrated and where, in the Commission’s assessment, they may aggravate the housing shortage.
What should a restriction justifyAfter the area has been delineated, Article 9 would require the authority to demonstrate a significant negative effect of short-term rentals on housing availability or affordability over a period of at least three years before the measure is adopted. Rentals may be one of several factors. Authorities should take into account, where available, the data collected under Regulation (EU) 2024/1028, which applies from 20 May 2026 and establishes rules for the collection and sharing of data concerning these services.
The draft also requires the authority to assess whether a less restrictive measure would protect housing supply and affordability just as effectively within a reasonable period. Any restriction should be limited to the affected area and calibrated according to the scale, frequency or commercial nature of the activity. It could initially be adopted for no more than five years, with the possibility of extension if a reassessment confirms that the conditions continue to be met. Affected individuals and businesses could challenge the measure in court.
What rules would apply to the primary residence and existing measuresThe draft would exempt the host’s primary residence from the restrictions applied under this framework to protect housing affordability and availability. The distinction matters for those who occasionally rent out the home in which they live. Authorities could continue to apply rules based on other legitimate objectives, such as safety or combating noise, under the applicable law.
According to Article 14, measures adopted before the entry into force of any potential regulation would remain outside the new framework, and authorities could choose to reassess them under it. The Parliament and the Council are examining the proposal submitted by the Commission in September. In Parliament, the file is with the IMCO committee and awaits a committee decision.
Latest News
14:04
14:00
13:58
13:46
13:41
See more news